New Winona penny loafers in Italian spazzolato leather
Reviews
Fits true to size based on
103 customer reviewsFilter reviews 1 - 6 of 103 Reviews
What customers are saying:
Customers overwhelmingly rave about the classic design and versatile style of these penny loafers, noting that they elevate both casual and dressed-up looks. Many praise the high-quality look of the leather and the overall craftsmanship, making them a timeless addition to any wardrobe. A large number of customers appreciate how comfortable they are—whether right out of the box or after a very short break‐in period—and often mention that they deliver great value. Some customers have suggested considering personal fit preferences when ordering, and overall, the loafers remain a popular, stylish choice for everyday wear.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
mmash
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 18 to 24Body type: PetiteHeight: 5'5"Size Purchased: 7 1/3Fits true to size
Great loafer!
2 weeks agoI bought the light brown pair before and loved them so much I had to get it in black. Very little break in period, shiny good quality leather and soles, and fitted well. The wife was too wide for me so it bows out a bit but they were out of stock in the regular size. Would stick with standard size.
Helpful?melodyb
Fits true to size
Cute but not real leather
June 12, 2026Comfy right out of the box but these are not 100% leather, nor are they "glossy Italian leather." It's a synthetic material with a leather interior lining and leather sole. The main part of the shoe looks plastic-y because it is.
Helpful?Mackison
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 25 to 34Size Purchased: 7Fits true to size
Chic
May 29, 2026So chic. They definitely need some breaking in, but are so worth it!
Helpful?Fordoutof4
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 35 to 44Body type: AthleticHeight: 5'4"Size Purchased: 9Fits true to size
Low quality
May 20, 2026I love the style and fit. It’s very comfortable but I only had it for less than a month and the sole has already separated. I’m very disappointed.
Helpful?Response from J.Crew
May 21, 2026Been in touch via email to help!
Noniv
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 55 to 64Body type: HourglassHeight: 5'5"Size Purchased: 9Fits true to size
Great loafer
May 17, 2026Love these perfect classic loafer an comfortable.
Helpful?VO Girl
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 55 to 64Body type: Straight and slenderHeight: 5'6"Size Purchased: 7Fits true to size
Classic loafers but comfortable!
May 16, 2026I had a similar pair way back in the 80s when they were super popular and remembered those being stiff and tough to break in. Well these are like butter on your feet! Gorgeous update and nice rubber sole so you're not skating around on slick surfaces. So classic. They are now a great addition to my wardrobe.
Helpful?