Rating & Reviews
Fits true to size based on
15 customer reviewsWhat customers are saying:
Customers love how soft, cozy, and warm this dress feels, and many say it’s flattering and easy to wear for both casual and dressier occasions. The tartan print and smocked shape get a lot of compliments, and several customers found it true to size or slightly roomy, with a relaxed, comfy fit. A common note is that the style leans more toward a cozy loungewear or nightgown vibe, so it may be best for customers who want a softer, more casual look rather than a polished one. A few customers also wished for pockets and a bit more attention to the sleeves, but overall the dress is praised for comfort and cute style.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
Filter Reviews 1 - 3 of 15 Reviews
cara10
Age: 55 to 64Body type: Straight and slenderHeight: 5'8"Size Purchased: x-smallFits big
GREAT
February 8, 2022Soft fabric and easy dress to wear anytime. It runs a bit large as most pieces seem to be doing this last season. I am 5’8” 125lbs and the x-small was perfect.
Helpful?PAWC
Age: 25 to 34Height: 5'4"Size Purchased: X-smallFits true to size
Nice weight, perfect for holidays
January 15, 2022The black watch tartan is understated but really cute. The material is more flannel like than the other dresses J Crew offers in this smocked design. Flowy bottom hides the extra serving and dessert. Highly recommended!
Helpful?chnm
Age: 25 to 34Body type: Straight and slenderHeight: 5'7"Size Purchased: XSFits big
the coziest dress but inconsistent sizing
January 14, 2022I already have and love this dress in Indigo Plaid, and just couldn't pass up snagging this print too. Everything I loved about the Indigo Plaid are here: the versatility, the coziness (as are the things I didn't like so much, like the just-a-touch-too-short sleeves and lack of pockets). The fabric on this is even softer and closer to a true flannel than the Indigo Plaid, which I love. Annoyingly, though, the sizing is quite different between the two dresses. I'm normally a size 0-2 (32C, 25" waist). The XS in the Indigo Plaid was snug on me, to the point where I could have comfortably sized up to an S. In the Black Watch Tartan however, the XS fits but is on the verge of being too loose, and I kind of wish I had gotten an XXS. So if you have this dress in other prints, don't assume that the fit will be the same.
Helpful?