Reviews
Fits slightly big based on
7 customer reviewsFilter reviews 1 - 6 of 7 Reviews
What customers are saying:
Customers are really enjoying the modern update to a classic pencil skirt, praising its flattering cut, thoughtful design details like stylish buttons and functional pockets, and versatile style that works wonderfully from workdays to weekend outings. Many also appreciated the quality and fabric, with a nod to the skirt’s longer length and overall timeless appeal. A few customers suggested considering a size adjustment, as some found the fit to be a bit loose around the waist or running larger. Overall, the skirt is celebrated for its quality, design, and enduring style.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
Music57
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 65 or overBody type: HourglassHeight: 5'6"Size Purchased: 8Fits big
Very good summer skirt, the buttons elevate.
March 10, 2024One of my go to hot weather skirts. I wore this skirt many times on a trip to Paris and it was great in extremely hot weather. My only complaint about this fabric is that the black faded after two or three washings even though I did not put it in the dryer.
Helpful?Kathryn
Size Purchased: 00Fits big
Large
May 11, 2022Absolutely beautiful skirt in almost every way (real pockets, lining, quality material), except that it runs large and has a loose waist. I'm normally a 00 (23 waist, 24 hips), and the smallest size fits much larger. On the model, it looks like it fits perfectly right at the waist, but like with almost all J. Crew waists, it's baggy, loosely defined, the front is lower than the back, and sits at the hips instead of the waist. I had to get it taken in significantly for it to fit right.
Helpful?Skirtdiaries
Age: 45 to 54Body type: Curvy on topHeight: 5'6"Size Purchased: 10pFits true to size
Good cut, cheap buttons
April 29, 2022Love the lightness and cut. Got black to have a basic work piece for hot Michigan summer. TTS but I can’t stand the buttons. Am having them replaced because they are very cheap looking and detract from the skirt.
Helpful?Urazid
Age: 55 to 64Body type: Curvy on topHeight: 5'5"Size Purchased: Size 2Fits big
Classic Feminine Style
April 22, 2022I ordered the Gentle Sea color of this skirt in my usual size 4. The color is a beautiful pale blue and the skirt is well made. I consider it to be a new timeless classic that will serve me for many years to come. It runs a whole size larger, so I had to return it for a size 2.
Helpful?Loulou
Age: 35 to 44Body type: Curvy on bottomHeight: 5'6"Size Purchased: 2Fits true to size
Gorgeous classy skirt!
April 17, 2022I've been having trouble finding nice fitting pencil skirts. That is until I ordered this one. WOW! I'm blow away how nice the fit is. Too many pencil skirts are just a straight cut making them either sit on the hip bone or gapping at the waist if pulled up higher. Not this one! It hugs the curves without being tight. Sexy but in a sophisticated way. I love that only the two bottom buttons are functional (it does have a back zipper). The length is another nice bonus - very classy looking. It does wrinkle a bit but that is expected since it is over 60% linen. Great job on this one J.Crew.
Helpful?Emily
Age: 35 to 44Body type: HourglassHeight: 5'7"Size Purchased: 6Fits small
So flattering!
April 1, 2022I love the quality of this skirt--the buttons are lovely and the length was flattering on me. I felt very va-va voom . . . I don't love my wide hips and smaller waist, but this skirt was incredibly flattering on my shape. It's hard to say if this skirt actually runs small or if I've just gained a few pounds. The skirt fit, but I think it would be tight to sit in all day, so I'm going to size up.
Helpful?