New Winona lug-sole penny loafers in Italian spazzolato leather
Rating & Reviews
Fits slightly big based on
23 customer reviewsWhat customers are saying:
Customers love the classic look of these loafers, especially the polished leather and lug sole, which give them a stylish but easy-to-wear vibe. Most reviewers said they felt comfortable right away or after a very short break-in, and many mentioned they pair well with everything from jeans to work outfits. The overall quality also got strong praise, with several customers saying the shoes feel well made and hold up nicely with regular wear.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
Filter Reviews 1 - 3 of 23 Reviews
TPL26
Age: 55 to 64Body type: Curvy on topSize Purchased: 11Fits big
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Beautiful, But Runs Big
2 weeks agoI love the look of these, but they run at least half a size too big. I’m normally a J.Crew size 11 and ordered my usual size, but they’re literally flopping off my feet when I walk. I’m still deciding whether to keep them or exchange them for a half size smaller. With fall coming, I’d like to wear them with socks, so I don’t want them to be too snug. That said, my usual size is definitely too big without socks. Beautiful shoes—just consider sizing down!
Helpful?JieJoanna
Age: 35 to 44Body type: PetiteFits true to size
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
New Winona lug sole penny loafers
June 22, 2026I like how it fits my feet; they fit perfectly. If the leather is softer, I would rate them 5 stars.
Helpful?MissMarci
Size Purchased: 10.5Fits true to size
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Breaking In But Worth It
May 27, 2026They look great! They’re taking a while to break in, but that expected with this style/material of penny loafer. Run TTS
Helpful?