It's a beautiful, feminine shirt and of great quality!

I love the ruffle details and machine washable feature. Great addition to my white blouse collection. It is a bit see through for me.

Already have the pink stripe in this shirt and love it. Decided to have the White also. It has been nice to see a different style of neckline. It is versatile and can be worn under various sweaters, cardigans etc. very feminine, fun.

I loved the idea of this, and it looked cute under sweaters, but only pullovers, as even a nude-for-me bra was visible through the translucent fabric. Just keep in mind what purpose you want it for and whether that's a dealbreaker. It also ran very wide through the arms and the waist, though that's to be expected with the classic fit.

I wanted to love this as the styling is so on point, but the fit and fabric quality are not up to regular standards. All my Jcrew is this size (XS) but this shirt was tight and didn't fit regularly to size. The button holes were sewn too closely where the buttons didn't open - you have to force each one through the hole. Also the cotton fabric was thin and scratchy. You'd have to wear an undershirt - it's too see-through.

This shirt has a cute collar but the fit is odd. The body is big (I ordered 1 size down) and the sleeves are very short. I hope Jcrew makes tall shirts again with longer sleeves. It's absurd to have sleeves so short.