I really struggle with JCrew’s sizing. The small is too small on some items, but just right on others. To be on the safe side, I ordered a medium. Holy cow! I’m swimming in it. I washed it right away and put it in the dryer hope it would shrink (because other sweaters from JCrew have done that) but no luck there. I’d wear it as a pajama top but the seams are itchy where the sleeves are gathered.

I’m not a puff sleeve girl but this one works. I tried the supercozy mock neck last year and didn’t like it at all. This is the same fabric but the style works with the fabric really well. I am normally a 10/12 in JCrew blouses (busty) and purchased this in a large. Fit is perfectly relaxed but not sloppy. Can wear this with sweats, jeans, or dress pants. A truly versatile piece. Heather Camel color is as pictured.

I didn’t find this oversized at all. It was not tight but the material is kind of slinky and clung to me - that in combination with a colour that was almost the same as my skin was not the look I was going for! Size medium, 5’8” and 150# 36C