Rating & Reviews
Fits big based on
11 customer reviewsWhat customers are saying:
Customers consistently praise this topcoat for its beautiful, high-quality Irish wool, solid construction, and versatile style that works dressed up or down. The fit tends to run large, so several customers suggested sizing down for a cleaner look. A few also noted that the shoulders are quite structured and can create a boxier silhouette, so those who prefer a slimmer shape may want to keep that in mind. Overall, it’s seen as a warm, polished coat that feels well worth it, especially when purchased on sale.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
Filter Reviews 1 - 3 of 11 Reviews
BrendanD
Age: 35 to 44Body type: AthleticHeight: 5'7"Size Purchased: 36SFits big
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Size Down, but Beautiful
August 14, 2026I had to size down from my usual 40S to 36S (so just be aware of that). But other than that, the coat is absolutely beautiful
Helpful?Seandia
Age: 45 to 54Body type: Curvy on topHeight: 5'8"Size Purchased: 40Fits big
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Incredible quality
June 26, 2026Runs big by design. I have a 45” chest but sized down to a 40. Incredible quality, hope this is a BIFL coat
Helpful?Skip Chardonnay
Body type: TallHeight: 6'5"Size Purchased: 40LFits big
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Just Shy of Great
February 10, 2026Overall, I like this coat, but I wouldn't pay full price for it. I caught it on sale for $450 and that feels about right. I would agree with other reviewers that the heavily padded shoulders make the silhouette a little boxy, but I actually like the generous fit in the body and I especially appreciate the full length. The substantial fabric drapes nicely. I do wish the sleeves were cut with a similar allowance though, because they are more snug than I would like when I wear this over a suit jacket. They're fine over sweaters, however. My other complaint goes for a lot of J.Crew's clothing. They go through the effort to source quality fabrics, which is the case here, but then slap on the cheapest buttons they can find. They look acceptable from a distance, but up close you can see they are flimsy plastic with an unnaturally shiny finish. I do love the fabric, and I especially like the tartan print on the lining. To me, this is just a few tweaks shy of being worth their full asking price, but on sale it's a nice coat that I enjoy wearing.
Helpful?