Rating & Reviews
Fits slightly small based on
39 customer reviewsWhat customers are saying:
Customers generally like the curvy-toothpick cut for its flattering high rise and the way it gives a little extra room through the hips and thighs while still looking sleek. A very common note is that this black wash runs small and can feel tighter than other J.Crew curvy toothpick jeans, so many customers suggest sizing up, sometimes even more than one size. The denim is also seen as more structured and less stretchy than expected, which helps it hold its shape but can make it feel a bit less forgiving. Overall, the jeans get good marks for style and a true black look, especially from customers who want a skinny-jean fit with a more curvy-friendly shape.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
Filter Reviews 1 - 3 of 39 Reviews
Lohjones
Age: 35 to 44Body type: AthleticHeight: 5'6"Size Purchased: 24 + 25Fits small
no stretch in waist-size up!
March 17, 2022These are great pants and they look really good on. But they run very small. I’m always a 24 in curvy jeans and a 24/25 in regular toothpick jeans. But this pant I needed to size up at least one for them to fit. The 24 I couldn’t even pull up!!! They also have a slightly larger opening at the ankle. So it does not fit tightly like some Jcrew toothpick jeans do.
Helpful?jasmynedanita
Age: 35 to 44Body type: Curvy on bottomHeight: 5'8"Size Purchased: 30TFits small
Miserably Small
February 9, 2022Why J. Crew would make a "curvy" jean with only 2% elastane is beyond me, but these are noticeably uncomfortable and inflexible in comparison to other washes of the same style. I normally wear a 29 in the Curvy Toothpick jean, but bought these in a 30 due to the low stretch percentage - and I still could barely get them halfway up my thighs before I gave up. Sadly returning.
Helpful?Anon
Age: 55 to 64Body type: AthleticHeight: 5'5"Size Purchased: 26Fits small
Way too small
February 9, 2022I've bought many pairs of size 26 J Crew toothpick jeans, and most have fit perfectly; the one or two times I've gotten size 27, they've been too big. I guess that's why I ordered these jeans in 26, despite other customers' warning they run small. Really small! (Also uncomfortably high waisted — I'm so glad lower rise is coming back.) It's really annoying, since the jeans are marked final sale. J Crew, please size your jeans consistently!
Helpful?