Classic-fit washed cotton poplin shirt in Snowy Stewart tartan
Reviews
Fits big based on
8 customer reviewsFilter reviews 1 - 6 of 8 Reviews
What customers are saying:
Several customers commented on the shirt’s cut, noting it has an oversized, boxy silhouette with broader shoulders and extra fabric, and they recommended checking sizing or opting for a slimmer style if you prefer a more tailored look. Some customers shared varied experiences with fit—while one suggested sizing down for a flattering shape, others enjoyed the relaxed, oversized vibe. Many also raved about the festive tartan plaid pattern, classic design, and quality material that make it a fun, holiday-ready piece. Overall, customers found it stylish and versatile, perfect for pairing with jeans or layering under jackets.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
Lauralou
Age: 45 to 54Body type: Straight and slenderHeight: 5'3"Size Purchased: Size 4Fits true to size
Preppy plaid won’t disappoint
January 27, 2022Great button down. Fits true to size. If you are looking for a cute plaid shirt to wear under sweaters or vests this is perfect. Looks cute with jeans. Classic Jcrew style. Preppy and classic.
Helpful?vves
Age: 45 to 54Body type: Straight and slenderHeight: 5'5"Size Purchased: 4Fits big
Not as expected
January 23, 2022I buy a ton of J Crew shirts. Had high expectations for this as I loved the photo. However, it is just way too big.
Helpful?ChrissieD
Age: 55 to 64Body type: Straight and slenderHeight: 5'8"Size Purchased: 6Fits true to size
GREAT Holiday Shirt
December 17, 2021I typically don’t write reviews, but after reading a lot of the reviews, I thought I’d share. Received this as a birthday gift, and absolutely LOVE it. I felt TOTALLY fits TTS. I got the size 6 and looks great tucked completely or a half tuck. I’ve received many compliments from men and women. To me, a must have, and will wear for years to come. A J Crew classic!
Helpful?jonesm45
Age: 35 to 44Body type: AthleticHeight: 5'4"Size Purchased: 4 and 6Fits big
Big and boxy
December 8, 2021I wanted to love it, but it just didn't work. I'm 5'4", 135 and tried a size 4 and 6...it's just too boxy. It's also quite long for the shorter women out there...I tried tucking it into jeans, but between the wide body, extra fabric in the shoulders and length, it's a no. Quality and material are both nice, colors are holiday festive.
Helpful?Maizie
Age: 55 to 64Body type: Straight and slenderHeight: 5'9"Size Purchased: 6Fits true to size
Holiday perfection
November 30, 2021Everyone needs a tartan plaid shirt for the holidays and this one doesn't disappoint. Can't wait to wear this under my black Jcrew lady jacket and with jeans as well. Just a great fitting shirt . Purchased normal size 6.
Helpful?Kbay
Age: 45 to 54Body type: HourglassHeight: 5'6"Size Purchased: 8Fits true to size
Strange fit
November 26, 2021When I first looked at this shirt, I checked the size and buttons as I thought I had ordered a mens shirt. The cut is so strange- the shoulder seams seemed to sit far back and I could not get it to fit or look right. I love this type of plaid, but don't recommend this shirt.
Helpful?