Reviews
Fits slightly small based on
8 customer reviewsFilter reviews 1 - 6 of 8 Reviews
What customers are saying:
Customers really enjoyed the fresh take on a classic style with the quality Liberty fabric and organic cotton feel, making it a versatile option for fall looks. The fall color palette and stylish print were especially appreciated, as they easily mix with a variety of wardrobe pieces for both casual and smart outfits. While a few customers suggested trying a size adjustment for the best fit, the overall craftsmanship and polished design stood out as highlights. Overall, this Liberty shirt offers a pleasant update on a familiar favorite that works well for many styling needs.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
Linen lover
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 45 to 54Body type: Curvy on bottomHeight: 5'4"Size Purchased: 10Fits true to size
Not for curves
March 24, 2024These shirts are too long and narrow -- not for a curvy body. They are made for tall and slender women, without pronounced curves. This one is slim-fit, but even non slim-fit are not made for women who are not slender on the bottom. JCrew, please consider some style variety in dress shirts!
Helpful?Agnes C
Age: 45 to 54Body type: Curvy on bottomHeight: 5'8"Size Purchased: 16Fits small
Classic liberty!
March 17, 2023Great liberty print. Definitely on the slim side. Great quality.
Helpful?Tiffany
Age: 25 to 34Body type: PetiteHeight: 5'3"Size Purchased: 4Fits true to size
Cute pattern
February 8, 2023I find this shirt accurate to the sizing chart but smaller than the usual fit. I'm 5ft3, 120lbs, 29" waist and the 4 is a bit big on me (quite disappointed size I thought it was slim fit). It's pretty long for my frame so I have to wear it tucked in. The fit is so so, not very flattering since the sides are straight and not curved in to hug your waist.
Helpful?LabCruiser
Age: 45 to 54Body type: TallHeight: 5'9"Size Purchased: 8Fits true to size
Subtle & Lovely
January 23, 2023I purchased the Slim Fit Liberty Capel shirt in my usual J Crew size 8. The organic cotton feels lovely. It is easy to style under cardigans, jackets and pullovers, while looking polished on its own with ecru jeans. The colors are muted but work with much in my wardrobe. I tend towards a "Fall" color palette. I did find this more generous through the waist than previous slim fit shirts but the arms, length & shoulders fit well. I am comfortable in the size purchased. Sizing up would have been a mistake for me. For reference I am 5'9", 34B, 150 lbs. & long waisted. Overall I am very pleased with the purchase.
Helpful?GoGirl2
Age: 55 to 64Body type: HourglassHeight: 5'5"Size Purchased: 12Fits small
Lovely - Size Up for Slim Fit
November 10, 2022Just as described & pictured, this is a slim fit - from my experience a typical J Crew slim fit - and I always size up one size for those since I don't like my shirts tight and once washed this has always worked out swell. Color just as pictured too: a pale olive green. Lovely Liberty fabric - I have a couple others, also bought on sale. I don't understand the crits re absence of darts (? - I don't think any of my J Crew shirts have darts), odd cut (? - I don't see that). Another lovely Liberty shirt. I'm happy with it. Thanks, J Crew!
Helpful?Mitchy87
Size Purchased: 18Fits small
Too small and too large at the same time
November 9, 2022Per other reviews on this fit, I sized up; however, it still didn’t fit right. The sleeves and shoulders fit fine, but the waist is snug and the upper back is very loose. Other slim-fit shirts from J. Crew fit much better.
Helpful?