Reviews
Fits small based on
10 customer reviewsFilter reviews 1 - 6 of 10 Reviews
What customers are saying:
Most customers raved about the stylish and eye-catching design, especially loving the soft, metallic, and textured leather details that fit right in with current trends. Several customers mentioned that the shoe tends to run small and suggested ordering up or just a half size larger to ensure a comfortable fit. Many appreciated the cushioned footbed, supportive buckle, and overall comfort for all-day wear. In general, customers enjoyed the attractive look and feel of the shoes and simply recommended a slight sizing adjustment for the best experience.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
Adorbs
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 35 to 44Body type: HourglassHeight: 5'5"Size Purchased: 8Fits small
Not worth it
December 26, 2025I bought this to be in the trend of metallic shoes. Poorly made because the front wasn’t even. Very narrow and not for wide feet. Glad I got them on sale because the actual price is outrageous for terrible quality.
Helpful?PurpleShoes
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Fits small
Love metal color shoes
June 26, 2025I'm typically 8.5 in JCrew Shoes. After reading the reviews I went for 9, and they fit perfectly. If you are hesitating, the straps will help you keep the shoes in place anyway. Great price for leather shoes, too. Got 'em on sale.
Helpful?Eurochic in CT
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 35 to 44Body type: TallHeight: 5'9"Fits small
Super Elegant Mary Janes
May 10, 2025Gorgeous Crackled Metallic Leather/that goes with all the cool summer colours - snagged them during the recent sale 60% off already reduced price, took other reviewers advice and got half size up as the leather is soft/heel fits comfortably, the padded footbed makes them super for walking all day.
Helpful?Momo345
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 55 to 64Body type: PetiteHeight: 5'1"Size Purchased: 6.5Fits small
I love it
May 3, 2025Beautiful and comfortable I think it runs slightly small. Wanted to buy black one too but they were sold out.
Helpful?NMMG
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 18 to 24Body type: Curvy on bottomHeight: 5'6"Size Purchased: 11Fits small
Nice soft leather, half a size up is enough
April 29, 2025The product si both sturdy and soft with the leather upper. However, reviews said to size up, and I have wide feet so I did, but I don't think it was entirely necessary. I am typically size 10, and i bought a size 11, i think a 10.5 would have sufficed the 11 fits a bit too big and the soft leather will mold and expand with use. In summary, half a size up would have been enough. But I cannot return since I purchased them final sale, thankfully the buckle will help keep shoe in place when walking.
Helpful?Novakat
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 45 to 54Body type: AthleticHeight: 5'2"Size Purchased: 6.5Fits small
Love, love these flats
April 25, 2025I have never, ever been anything but a size 6, and based on these reviews I ordered a 6.5 with fingers crossed, as these were final sale. Perfection. This shoe is so cute and relative to many other JCrew shoe purchases over the years, a little bit more comfortable. The footbed actually has a tiny bit of cushion, and overall, the shoe feels nice on the foot, not like wearing a cardboard box, as with some other JCrew shoes I've bought in the last couple of years (shoes that look gorgeous but feel cheap when wearing). I am short, so usually opt for heels but these flats might convert me.
Helpful?