Reviews
Fits true to size based on
22 customer reviewsFilter reviews 1 - 6 of 22 Reviews
What customers are saying:
Customers really love these classic loafers for their versatile style and high-quality construction that works perfectly for both casual and dressy looks. Many rave about the comfortable feel after they break in, and they appreciate that the shoe’s timeless design keeps it in style year after year. While a few customers mentioned that the fit might require a slight adjustment, overall the emphasis is on how flattering and durable these shoes are. With compliments coming in from all angles, it's clear that this loafer has become a favorite staple for many.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
Letlely
Age: 35 to 44Body type: AthleticHeight: 5'7"Size Purchased: 9.5Fits true to size
Get them back for sale!
May 20, 2023Hands down the most classic shoes ever! As old as they are I always get compliments- I want to buy them again. Jcrew- please bring them back and just like the pennyloafers make them in several colors! I am sure just like me many would purchase again and again- these should be like the McAllister boot!!!
Helpful?Lola
Age: 45 to 54Body type: Straight and slenderHeight: 5'7"Size Purchased: 8Fits true to size
My favorite shoe!
June 5, 2022I bought these a few years ago, but they are so well-made that they are still in perfect condition. I put a tap on the heel to prevent it from wearing out and they are gorgeous!
Helpful?snowb12
Age: 35 to 44Height: 5'6"Size Purchased: 9.5Fits big
Favorite black loafer
June 24, 2021When the black pair were on sale over the holidays I immediately snapped them up - in my usual 9.5. They do run slightly big and if my feet didn’t swell over the course of the day, I’d for sure have to exchange for a 9. I loved the black pair so much I bought the brown this spring. Interestingly, the brown pair runs even bigger and J.Crew’s suggested size was 9 - they fit perfectly. Both colors are timeless and make any outfit look amazing and the leather is super high quality.
Helpful?Jnwm
Fits small
Narrow
March 17, 2021I have average-width feet. The brown version of these felt like bedroom slippers from the moment I put them on. These are noticeably stiffer and therefore the leather responds by holding the shoe’s narrow shape. Buy them. They’re gorgeous and of outstanding quality. Just be aware. For reference I wear a 9 and bought a 9. I have never needed wide width shoes. (Again, the brown ones are dreamy)
Helpful?Momofthree
Fits true to size
Great shoes
March 2, 2021I finally found a replacement for my old beloved loaders. They fit perfectly and get better every time I wear them. Nice quality!
Helpful?BConn
Age: 18 to 24Body type: Straight and slenderHeight: 5'6"Size Purchased: 5hFits big
Great quality and style, ran a little large
February 21, 2021I initially ordered in my usual 6, and it ran a little large so customer service sent me a 5h which fit perfectly. The exchange was completed very quickly--great job JCrew! I am so happy with these--they're more structured than most loafers on the market and formal enough to wear to work when I don't feel like wearing heels. Would buy similar styles again from JCrew.
Helpful?