Reviews
Fits slightly small based on
37 customer reviewsFilter reviews 1 - 6 of 37 Reviews
What customers are saying:
Customers really love the classic, refined design and excellent craftsmanship of these loafers, with many praising their unique, chunky sole and quality leather. There’s a bit of mixed feedback on sizing—some customers suggested ordering a half size up for a more comfortable fit while others found their regular size worked best—so it might be best to try them in-store when possible. A few noted that the shoes can feel firm at first, recommending a break‐in period to let them mold to your feet. Overall, the stylish look and solid construction make these loafers a popular pick for those who appreciate a classic update with a modern twist.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
MLMM
Age: 45 to 54Height: 5'7"Size Purchased: 7Fits small
Perfect loafer - slightly snug
April 3, 2023Super cute and very nice loafer. Very stylish. They're a bit small and snug. I have extremely narrow feet and these loafers are a little tight even on me. They're plenty long enough but the shoe itself is small and narrow.
Helpful?Shayla
Age: 25 to 34Size Purchased: 7.5Fits small
Poor, poor quality
March 9, 2023After wearing these shoes only 5 times the outer sole has split in the front. The bottom shoes look like they’re made of wood and have already broke after very light wear. I would not recommend these because you’ll just have to buy a new pair of loafers after a week of wear.
Helpful?Rem989
Age: 25 to 34Body type: PetiteHeight: 5'2"Size Purchased: 6 1/2Fits big
Very pretty
February 12, 2023I had been eyeing this for a while even though I told myself that my hunt for loafers was over ever since I bought two pairs of Everlane loafers (discontinued but made of beautiful Italian leather) a couple of years ago. However, they're so loud when I walk I decided I may need a different pair of loafers for work. So these ones caught my eye but I stopped myself from buying them since the reviews were all over the place. Finally my size came back into stock and I decided to just buy my normal size. I've always been a 6 1/2, so that's what I ordered and crossed my fingers since they were final sale. I expected them to be a bit tight but to my surprise, they're actually a bit loose when I walk, my heel almost slips out. I'm hoping to break into them more to see if that helps, but for the most part they fit and they look really high quality. However, they are still a bit loud when I walk and I wouldn't say they fit me *perfectly*
Helpful?Dider
Age: 45 to 54Body type: HourglassHeight: 5'5"Size Purchased: 9Fits true to size
True to size
February 4, 2023These are true to size so don’t size up. I think a little big if anything. At least in the ganache colour. Very sturdy need to be broken in for sure!
Helpful?Mencho
Age: 45 to 54Body type: Straight and slenderHeight: 5'7"Size Purchased: 8.5Fits true to size
Runs true to its size
February 4, 2023I have many moccasins from J CREW, all of them are 8.5 and this pair is also 8.5 they fit me PERFECT. Reading other reviews I was wondering to order a size 9, but luckily I took the risk buying my real size and they fit me great. My foot is not narrow at all, and I fit size 9 in sandals.
Helpful?Mags
Age: 45 to 54Body type: AthleticHeight: 5'4"Size Purchased: 8.5Fits small
Gorgeous Loafer
January 31, 2023Received these loafers today on mega sale! I’m OBSESSED! These are SOOOO good! These would be a great deal full price. Excellent craftsmanship, quality shoe, well worth the $$. Classic, stylish and slightly chunky sole.. LOVE Highly recommend ( I did go up a half size and I’m glad I did) They will need a breaking in period but I’m here for it! 10/10 Old school Jcrew quality
Helpful?