Reviews
Fits small based on
18 customer reviewsFilter reviews 1 - 6 of 18 Reviews
What customers are saying:
Many customers really enjoyed the soft, buttery leather and cushioned footbed, noting that the sandals add a stylish, elevated touch to any summer outfit. The design and quality were generally well-received, making these sandals a versatile pick for both casual and dressed-up days. A number of customers suggested trying a half size up as the fit tended to run a bit small for optimal comfort. Overall, once the right size was found, the sandals delivered on comfort and style.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
Bon727
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Fits small
Badly made causing sandals to be too small
July 22, 2025Horrible sizing. Something about the way they're made makes it impossible to wear them. While the length of the sandals was right the top stripe that goes in between toes was placed too low on the sole resulting entire foot being slightly pushed downward the sandal. I was refused to return it since the return window passed and I ddin't try them on time for the return. Tried to wear them and even fix them with shoemaker nothing worked. I had to give them to second hand shop.
Helpful?Ladidadi
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 35 to 44Body type: HourglassHeight: 5'5"Size Purchased: 7Fits true to size
Great Design, Odd Fit
June 12, 2025Close, but no cigar! Glad I bought these on super duper sale, so I'm not terribly disappointed - but I am, frankly, a little surprised. There was clearly thought in the design, and I appreciate the padding in a flip flop. They're walkable, and the blue color is very pretty and fresh. The leather is nice and soft, and doesn't dig into your feet like many strappy sandals do. They are weirdly narrow, though - and I have fairly narrow feet, so I can't really see people with flatter arches or wider feet finding these very comfortable. The way that the straps are attached closest to your ankle are kind of off, too - the outer strap feels like it's pulled a bit too tight, and my feet feel like they're pushed to the inner part of the shoe. I'd love to see a tweaking of the style - the colors and simplicity of the design are timeless and I'd love to potentially have several colors.
Helpful?Juju17
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 18 to 24Body type: Straight and slenderHeight: 5'5"Fits true to size
Italian Summer Sandals
March 4, 2024Just a tad small, more slender than other sandals. But still comfortable
Helpful?PLST
Age: 55 to 64Body type: AthleticHeight: 5'5"Size Purchased: 7 1/2Fits true to size
Menorca padded thong sandal
January 19, 2024Sandals are cushioned and very comfortable - great for my vacation walking around pool and lobby and casual walking.
Helpful?Bon727
Age: 45 to 54Body type: PetiteHeight: 5'4"Size Purchased: 6hFits small
Misfitting catastrophie
November 6, 2023Please dont ignore the reviews as I did. I ordered those and before Ive tried them it was too late to return. Something is terribly misfit here. They should be reimbursed due to the faulty manufacturing. I'm a typical 6h, never more never less, very slim feet. The strap is to deep into the sole, my heel sticks out, walking for more than 5 minutes hurts. Shame on JCrew for not taking it off the shelves. Other than that they're beautiful.
Helpful?hkcamp
Age: 45 to 54Body type: PetiteHeight: 5'3"Size Purchased: 7Fits big
very stiff
September 8, 2023These look very nice, but are very stiff! Not sure how long it will take to break them in if possible.
Helpful?