I absolutely loved this cropped sweater! It fits true to size and was exactly the style I was looking for. While I usually wear a small, I did wonder if a medium might have worked too. Unfortunately, I made the mistake of not following the care instructions—it’s dry clean only, and I thought cold water on a delicate setting would be enough. It shrunk, and I’ve definitely learned my lesson to always follow the recommended care instructions, especially for a sweater as nice as this one. Despite this, I hope it comes back in stock because it’s such a great piece, and I’d happily repurchase. Yes, it was an expensive lesson, but totally worth it for how much I loved it!

Literally obsessed with it, so soft, warm, and a great fit with high-rise jeans. Wish there were more colors available! Note, it does run a bit small, I usually wear M (5'9, size 10), however, went for X-Large and it fist perfectly, a bit oversize - just the way it should

I kept this one in my cart for so long before deciding to buy because of the high price tag! Super bummed to find that the fabric is so itchy it’s unwearable unless you have a long sleeve on. The cropped shape and wide cut is also super strange. Hard pass. Wish I could return.

This sweater is too cropped if you are on the taller side. Also, be aware it’s wool and is pretty itchy imo.

I got this in the blue and find it very comfy. I have sensitive skin but as a layering piece it doesn’t feel scratchy at all. It is a lofty knit that pills but I have worn it a ton since receiving it so I guess it’s expected. I’m 5’3”, 114 lbs and purchased Medium which suits me better than my usual Small. (I sized up due to the cropped length. The sweater hits at my hip which I love because it looks great with high waisted jeans. It was a great price so I’m ok with the pilling. (The J Crew Sweater comb does the trick for them.)

I got the green and the color is very nice and I probably got one good wear. After one or two washes it looked like a sweater that was 20 years old. Terrible quality, tons of pilling, I mean the sweater is falling apart. Jcrew - do better.