Rating & Reviews
Fits true to size based on
219 customer reviewsWhat customers are saying:
Customers love the classic penny loafer look, rich leather finish, and how easy these are to wear with jeans, pants, skirts, and work outfits. Many say they’re comfortable and true to size, though a number of customers noted a narrow or slightly small fit and suggested sizing up if they want extra room. A common theme is that the leather can feel stiff at first, but it usually softens after a few wears and becomes much more comfortable. Overall, they’re seen as a stylish, versatile loafer that gets a lot of wear once broken in.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
Filter Reviews 1 - 3 of 219 Reviews
Love these loafers
Age: 65 or overBody type: HourglassHeight: 5'11"Size Purchased: 9.5Fits true to size
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Love these classic loafers!
April 9, 2026Please do NOT discontinue these loafers!! That are my favs - I have them in every color and am looking to purchase a second pair of each. I have had them for years, wear them constantly and they still look good. But nothing looks good forever. Please!, don’t discontinue!
Helpful?HGreta
Age: 25 to 34Body type: PetiteHeight: 5'0"Size Purchased: 5Fits true to size
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Perfect little loafer
May 18, 2025Perfect loafer. I was nervous they would be too shiny but I love the way they look in black. They fit true to size, which is nice because I often have a hard time finding shoes that fit my size 5 feet.
Helpful?annie987
Size Purchased: 7.5Fits true to size
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Poor Quality
April 15, 2025I worse these maybe 4 times before the sole started separating from the upper. Seems like a serious quality issue and because I was out of the return window there was no recourse. Fairly disappointing cost per wear. If you have a bony ankle the shoe also rubs pretty badly and is quite stiff.
Helpful?Response from J.Crew
April 16, 2025We've reached out to look into this and help.