Ruffleneck puff-sleeve dress in Liberty® fabric

I'm between the size XS and S, and purchased, despite the other reviews, the S. unlike the other reviewers, I find it true to size, it is slightly big because are supposed to be pleats once tied…I find it flattering and very cute (and I'm far from being shaped like a Christmas tree as someone has suggested). I wish I had purchased the yellow one too! (As a reference: I’m broad shouldered and slim)

This is awful, it looks like a bag with a tie around the waist. The quality isn’t bad but I don’t love the fabric. It runs very large. Final sale so I can’t return.

Totally agree with other review. I’m 5ft 103#, bought the XXS for the fact that it’s cotton and leopard print but it’s huge, stiff (maybe washing first will help) and has a terrible neckline for petites. The cheap strings only add to the lack of quality this piece offers. Perhaps black boots and a suede belt will help it. Surprised by Jcrew-

I wish that there had been a review of this dress before I bought it, so that I would know just how ridiculously large it is. I’m 5’1” and weigh 165 lbs wear a large in most brands. I do often size down to medium in a lot of J Crew’s summer dresses, and sometimes even a small, but that is more about their wildly inconsistent sizing. But this dress is weird and unwearable - I look like I was swallowed whole by a leopard print paper bag. The wrist openings are very large (they don’t even touch my wrists), the material is stiff and there’s a ton of it, with a hemline that is awkwardly long. It wouldn’t be as bad if I’d sized down or if they had used a lighter material, but here we are. It’s times like this when I still wonder why I buy non-returnable items from J. Crew, especially if there isn’t a review for size guidance.

This dress runs very large and it ballons out like a paper bag at the bottom. Something is terribly wrong with the cut. UNLESS YOU ARE SHAPED LIKE A CHRISTMAS TREE, IT WILL NOT COMPLIMENT YOUR FIGURE AT ALL. The model (yellow dress) seems to be having the same issues. The photos clearly show that there is wayyy to much fabric in the hip area. The model in the animal print seems to have it pinned in back to get a good fit. This is such a disappointment. I love the print and fabric, but this dress is not wearable, without some serious/expensive tailoring.