Rating & Reviews
Fits true to size based on
7 customer reviewsWhat customers are saying:
Customers generally like these derbys for their polished look, smooth leather, and solid craftsmanship, and several mention that they feel like a great upgrade from other dress shoes. Comfort and break-in get good marks too, with a few customers saying they felt good right away and softened up quickly. Fit is mostly good overall, though a couple of customers suggested sizing down a bit since they run slightly large.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
Filter Reviews 1 - 3 of 7 Reviews
Aaron E
Fits true to size
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Great shoes
August 8, 2026High quality leather, great fit
Helpful?DerbyShoeWearer
Age: 55 to 64Body type: Straight and slenderHeight: 5'10"Size Purchased: 9Fits small
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Right shoe squeaks loudly
July 3, 2026I a bought a pair and the right shoe makes a loud squeaking sound when I walk. It’s embarrassing walking down the corridor at work. I’ve worn them several times hoping they will break in and the squeaking will stop. Unfortunately, the squeaking sound seems to be getting worse. This is very bad. I’ve purchased derby shoes from J.Crew before and not had this problem. J.Crew, what do I do?
Helpful?Response from J.Crew
July 5, 2026Oh no, we sent an email to help!
Fits true to size
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Dress shoes
April 30, 2026Good quality and broken in quickly
Helpful?