Rating & Reviews
Fits slightly small based on
466 customer reviewsWhat customers are saying:
Customers love this Jackie cardigan as a classic, versatile staple that’s easy to dress up or down, especially for work and layering. It comes in lots of colors, and many people keep buying it season after season because it’s such a handy closet basic. A common note is to size up if you want a less fitted look or plan to wear it over layers, since it tends to run small. Some customers also felt the newer fabric is a bit thinner or less soft than older versions, so that’s worth keeping in mind if you prefer a richer cotton feel.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
Filter Reviews 1 - 3 of 466 Reviews
Ruby212
Age: 55 to 64Body type: AthleticHeight: 5'5"Size Purchased: mediumFits small
Please Bring Back the Jackie Cardigans
April 6, 2022The Jackie Cardigan is a mainstay of my business wardrobe and I have amassed about a dozen of these sweaters over my career. As the cardigans age, I want to replace them, and the alternative you offer do not compare. Please, please, please bring these back.
Helpful?Helen
Age: 25 to 34Body type: Curvy on topHeight: 5'4"Size Purchased: 3xFits small
Plus size opinion
November 21, 2021I really wanted these to work for me, but they simply won’t. I’m an apple-shaped plus size woman, and I struggle to find a classic cardigan. I purchased two colors really looking forward to them working out, and they haven’t. They’re on the small size which is weird since they’re suppose to go over your clothing. As mentioned in other reviews, I have large arms, which makes an already reduced cardigan feel even more reduced. I would steer clear of them if you’re plus size and broader or have ample bat wings. The fabric also wants soft or cozy feeling. I kept thinking I will give to my sister who is two dress sizes smaller than me.
Helpful?Bella
Age: 18 to 24Body type: Straight and slenderHeight: 5'8"Size Purchased: XSFits small
Very sexy staple
November 4, 2021I tow the line at J.Crew between XS and S. I’m pretty slender, but I have a large chest and my waist fluctuates greatly depending on my lifestyle/time-of-the-month. I bought this cardigan in XS because I wanted it to be form-fitting. I wear it buttoned up with no shirt underneath and it is very, very sexy on. It’s the perfect material - stretchy, thick enough, and not itchy or uncomfortable to sweat in. It almost feels a little sporty. I wear this with yoga pants and *no bra* and I look sexy without being revealing! My advice: size slightly down and treat this as your sophisticated yet sexy piece. I’m praying the material holds up because I want to keep this forever!
Helpful?